Gigabyte v. Asus – the sequel

May 22, 2008 | 09:37

Tags: #des #epu #grow-up #name-calling

Companies: #asus #gigabyte

The fight between motherboard manufacturers Asus and Gigabyte continues today, with neither side willing to concede.

The spat began with Gigabyte's claims that an energy saving chip invented by Asus was nothing more than smoke and mirrors, calling the technology – which Asus claims can offer CPU power savings of up to 80 percent when idle - “fake” and “pure[ly] software based, not hardware.”

If Gigabyte had left it there, it would simply have been an unremarkable event, but the company – in a fit of pique that a seven-year old would have been proud of – went on to accuse Asus of “cheating end users” and remarked that “everything Asus say are lies.” in a presentation on the technology released to press. Which wasn't very politic, really.

As we reported yesterday, Asus has rubbished the claims of its competitor and is even threatening legal action against Gigabyte for spreading such “disinformation,” but Gigabyte isn't finished yet.

In a statement released to press, the company has re-iterated that the comments it made came from “direct comparisons and testing results [...] between the Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS3L motherboard and our competitor's P5K-SE EPU.” The company goes on to apologise for “any confusion this situation may have caused our competitor's customers,” but vows to “stand by our statements and testing report 100 percent, and eagerly await our competitor to clarify the issues we raised in order to avoid any further confusion.

Gigabyte also took the opportunity to have a swipe at claims by Asus that the Energy Processing Unit technology was “an Asus exclusive hardware implementation,”, pointing out that it has a similar technology it dubs Dynamic Energy Saver featuring up to six “gears” compared to the EPU's two.

While the language of this latest press release is a great deal more circumspect than the last to come from Gigabyte – you won't find the words “liars” or “fake” for a start – the general thrust is a rather belligerent “we think we're right, so sue us if you can prove us wrong.” The company even takes the opportunity to have a subtle dig at Asus in the closing paragraph, claiming that Gigabyte “promises to continue providing higher quality, better spec and greater performance products to our customers,” without going so far as to add the rider “than Asus” that was clearly in the author's mind at the time. The piece closes with a thinly-veiled accusation that its rival is playing catch-up, claiming “other motherboard manufacturers have followed [our] lead by introducing higher quality components on their products,” again being careful not to name names.

Whatever the truth behind Gigabyte's claims, I can't help but feel they're – to borrow a phrase – writing cheques their body can't cash. Still, the ball is now in Asus's court, and this game of schoolyard name-calling doesn't look to be over yet. Whether Asus will respond with yet more empty threats or a full analysis comparing the EPU technology to Gigabyte's DES and disproving its competitor's claims, or even the vague possibility of a lawsuit between the two, remains to be seen.

Has this latest salvo made you change sides in the Geek Fight of the Motherboard Manufacturers, or do you think that the two should just grow up and concentrate on making the best products they can instead of slagging off their competitors? Share your thoughts over in the forums.
Discuss this in the forums
YouTube logo
MSI MPG Velox 100R Chassis Review

October 14 2021 | 15:04