Alpenföhn K2 Mount Doom Review

August 30, 2013 | 08:05

Tags: #air-cooling #cpu-cooler #heatsink #installation #lga-1150 #lga1150 #noctua-nh-d14 #silver-arrow

Companies: #alpenfohn

Performance Analysis

In our LGA1155 test system, the K2 produces full speed and PWM delta T results that are on par with the excellent Noctua NH-D14, which retains an advantage by being slightly quieter in both cases. While impressive, its results still fall short of the Phanteks PH-TC14PE and Thermalright's SilverArrow SB-E Extreme, although the latter is an extremely loud cooler. Using the 7V fan speed adaptor sees the delta T rise to 44°C, which is again impressive given that in this state the cooler is all but silent.

Despite a promising start, performance on our LGA2011 test rig is sadly a little disappointing. At full speed, a result of 48°C is good but not quite as low as we were hoping for, with each of the other large, dual tower coolers able to beat it. Using the 7V cable causes things to heat up dramatically, with our chip reaching within 10°C of its thermal limit and producing a final delta T result of 60°C, which is far worse than the NH-D14 fitted with its own low noise adaptor, which comes out with a delta T of just 49°C. Evidently, the low airflow at this speed is insufficient to handle this toasty, overclocked set-up.

Alpenföhn K2 Mount Doom Review Alpenföhn K2 Mount Doom - Performance Analysis and Conclusion
Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

Conclusion

The K2 has lots to boast about both in terms of raw performance and aesthetics, but the Phanteks PH-TC14PE still trumps it on both counts here, although it is slightly more expensive. The similarly priced Noctua NH-D14, however, is its true competition given that it's also geared towards silent operation. This cooler also has a slight edge on Alpenföhn's, especially at lower noise levels where the K2 appears to struggle slightly in more demanding set-ups. Coupled with a few irritations regarding its installation, where Noctua also happens to excel, the K2 just misses the mark when it comes to justifying not only its price, but its massive size and weight too.

That said, the K2 is by no means awful, and adding it to your system would almost certainly give you very healthy CPU temperatures and a low noise output. However, all things considered, it still leaves us wanting a little more.

Intel LGA1155 Score

Alpenföhn K2 Mount Doom Review Alpenföhn K2 Mount Doom - Performance Analysis and Conclusion
Click to enlarge


Intel LGA2011 Score

Discuss this in the forums

Posted by Corky42 - Fri Aug 30 2013 08:28

Naming something meant to keep CPU cool after a hot, flaming, lava spewing volcano, what where they thinking.
And with only 5c separating the top 10 air HS, is there much reason to choose one over another ?
Especially when the case and fans used can make more difference than that.

Posted by SchizoFrog - Fri Aug 30 2013 11:28

If you can live with the small sacrifices concerning the name, the cooling performance and a little extra noise then this is definitely a cooler to seriously consider. It has to be said that it is one damn smart piece of hardware and in my opinion is far superior in that respect than all the other massively sized air coolers.

Posted by Farfalho - Fri Aug 30 2013 11:33

I will go on the off-topic route to make a simple question:
Why hasn't been a new AMD rig for tests purposes since the last one died?

Posted by jrs77 - Fri Aug 30 2013 13:23

The biggest problem for air-cooling your components is still the crappy interiror layout of PC-cases. If you have unhindered airflow from front to back of the case then you can lower the deltaT even more then by using these massive coolers with two or more fans attached.

Think of a 120mm diameter tube from front to back with the cooler inbetween. That's the best you can do actually and it's quiet easily doable with a flexible airduct. You wouldn't even need a front-intake or a fan attached to the cooler itself in that setup but only an exhaust in the back that draws the air through the duct.
null
  • Cooling
    33 / 40
  • Design
    23 / 30
  • Value
    23 / 30

Score guide
Where to buy

Overall 79%
YouTube logo
MSI MPG Velox 100R Chassis Review

October 14 2021 | 15:04

In line with recent changes to data protection legislation in the UK and Europe we would like to direct you to our updated Privacy Policy here.